As Long Island’s only public research university, Stony Brook produces the innovations and the educated workforce that drive the area’s economy.
Part I:Executive Summary |
Part II:Introduction |
Part III:The University's Impact on the Long Island Community A. Economic Development |
Part IV:The University's Impact on Earnings A. Economic Development |
Part V:The University's Impact on Jobs A. Economic Development |
Part VI: Putting it all Together - Aggregate Effects A. Total Impact on Long Island’s Economy, Earnings and Jobs
|
Part VII:Apendices |
Part VIII: References |
Stony Brook University is a major asset and contributor to the Long Island economy. The University is Long Island’s largest single-site employer, employs more than 2,500 full- and part-time faculty and provides nearly 16,000 people with full- or part-time jobs. As Long Island’s only public research university, Stony Brook produces the educated workforce that drives the area’s high-tech economy.
The economic importance of Stony Brook for Long Island’s economy is apparent just by considering the University’s operating expenses in its financial statements. Stony Brook’s total operating expenses for 2016 were $2.69 billion, an increase of approximately $689 million since the last study of Stony Brook’s economic impact was conducted in 2008, and an increase of more than $1.5 billion in the 13 years since the 2003 impact study was completed. Stony Brook provides tremendous value to its students.
Stony Brook University Hospital accounts for more than 50 percent of revenues, with state appropriations contributing 21 percent. Grants and contracts collectively account for 10 percent of revenues. Given its multiple funding sources, tuition and fees account for just 11 percent of its revenues.
Looking at the many programs and activities funded with these dollars, it is clear that Stony Brook’s wide-ranging mission includes a focus on undergraduate and graduate education, research, community service and economic development — all of which enrich the surrounding region.
But the raw expenses alone do not demonstrate to a sufficient degree just how integral Stony Brook is to the regional economy. Any organization that creates employment and income generates secondary effects in the area’s economy in additional employment and income, which is the result of spending and re-spending income. These effects are distinct from the impact of direct expenditures and are generally categorized as indirect economic impacts. The total economic impact of the organization is then obtained by adding together these direct and indirect effects. The approach for quantifying these direct and indirect effects — known as the multiplier methodology — is described in Appendix A.
Faculty Status | Number |
---|---|
Full Time | 1,867 |
Tenured | 712 |
Tenure Track | 295 |
Non-tenure track | 860 |
Part Time | 828 |
Tenured | 30 |
Tenure Track | 10 |
Non-tenure track | 788 |
Data Source: IPEDS Data Center. Prepared by the Office of Institutional Research, Planning & Effectiveness, April 11, 2017
Employment Setting | Number |
---|---|
Academic | 3,834 |
Non-academic | 5,055 |
Hospital | 7,007 |
Total | 15,896 |
Payroll | |
Monthly Payroll | $91 Million |
Data Source: Annual Financial Report, Stony Brook University, 2016
Year | Revenue ($ Billions) |
---|---|
2016 | 2.28 |
2008 | 1.64 |
2003 | 1.26 |
Data Sources: Annual Financial Report, Stony Brook University, 2003, 2008, 2016
Year | Revenue ($ Billions) |
---|---|
2016 | 2.28 |
2008 | 1.83 |
2003 | 1.64 |
Data Sources: Annual Financial Report, Stony Brook University, 2003, 2008, 2016;
Consumer Price Index
Revenue Source | Amount ($ Millions) | % of Total |
---|---|---|
Hospital | 1,170.2 | 51 |
State Appropriations | 470.7 | 21 |
Tuition & Fees | 244.6 | 11 |
Federal Grant & Contacts | 141.2 | 6 |
State, Local and Private Grants & Contracts | 93.5 | 4 |
Auxiliary Enterprises | 89.8 | 4 |
Non-Operating Revenues | 69.7 | 3 |
Data Source: Annual Financial Report, Stony Brook University, 2016
There are a number of factors that contribute to Stony Brook’s large and diverse benefits to Long Island’s economy that provide an indirect economic stimulus to the regional economy far beyond that which appears in the University’s direct expenditures. These include the following:
Beyond these financial capital impacts, as a large public research university that offers very affordable in-state tuition, Stony Brook provides opportunities for students to graduate from college and graduate school programs who might not otherwise be able to do so. Thus, Stony Brook enhances human capital as well, educating students who become more productive workers and contribute enormously to the Long lsland economy.
The approach used to estimate enhanced worker productivity effects is described in Appendix B.
Stony Brook’s economic development initiatives spur economic growth. These programs enable some $234 million in indirect output through joint projects with industry partners that increase these companies’ sales revenues, contracts, grants and awards they receive, and private capital they raise. Additional support from Vice President of Economic Development (VPED)* programs leads to a total of $234.3 million in economic development.
Category | Direct Effect | Indirect Effect | Total Effect |
---|---|---|---|
Economic Development | $654,024** | $233,607,654 | $234,261,678 |
* Now a part of the Office of the Vice President for Research
** This expenditure of a portion of a Long Island Regional Economic Development Council (REDC) award, for design of an addition to the Advanced Energy Center, is this year’s only direct expenditure of awarded economic development funds that can be separated from campus and Research Foundation operating expenditures elsewhere categorized. The 2015–16 total of REDC-awarded funds was $5.5 million.
Stony Brook’s operating expenditures alone have a strong economic impact. In addition to the direct expenditures — some $2.69 billion in 2016 — the indirect effects nearly double this amount, so that the full economic impact of operating expenditures exceeds $5.22 billion. Nearly half of this economic impact, $2.48 billion, is attributable to hospital services. Other categories of expenditures, including instruction and research, have large impacts as well.
Category | Direct Effect | Indirect Effect | Total Effect |
---|---|---|---|
Instruction | $410,333,037 | $381,240,425 | $791,573,462 |
Research | $112,967,711 | $104,958,300 | $217,926,011 |
Public Service | $27,185,116 | $25,257,691 | $52,442,807 |
Academic Support | $86,225,256 | $71,247,929 | $157,473,185 |
Student Services | $50,897,081 | $47,288,478 | $98,185,559 |
Institutional Support | $123,353,848 | $101,927,285 | $225,281,133 |
Operation & Maintenance | $89,408,641 | $71,392,800 | $160,801,441 |
Scholarships & Fellowships | $25,727,426 | $23,903,351 | $49,630,777 |
Auxiliary Enterprises | $85,581,054 | $66,984,291 | $152,565,345 |
Hospital Services | $1,254,465,216 | $1,220,845,548 | $2,475,310,764 |
Dental Services | $1,372,934 | $1,288,773 | $2,661,707 |
Clinical Services | $356,195,168 | $334,360,404 | $690,555,572 |
Other Expenses & Deductions | $8,473,755 | $7,872,966 | $16,346,721 |
Interest Expenses | $58,655,400 | $71,154,866 | $129,810,266 |
Total | $2,690,841,643 | $2,529,723,107 | $5,220,564,750 |
Table 8 indicates that construction spending by Stony Brook was approximately $274 million in 2016. Expenditures on land, equipment and interest payments account for an additional $48 million, making total capital expenditures of nearly $323 million in 2016. In addition to these direct expenditures, multiplier effects increase output by nearly $268 million, so that the total economic impact of capital expenditures by Stony Brook was more than $590 million in 2016.
Category | Direct Efect | Indirect Effect | Total Effect |
---|---|---|---|
Construction | $274,093,044 | $226,318,636 | $500,411,680 |
Equipment | $27,695,531 | $21,965,326 | $49,660,857 |
Land | $8,565,798 | $4,760,014 | $13,325,812 |
Interest Expenses | $12,319,078 | $14,944,274 | $27,263,352 |
Total | $322,673,451 | $267,988,250 | $590,661,701 |
Much of the economic impact of student education and living is contained in the University’s financial statements, especially in the tuition, dormitory income and Faculty Student Association funds. But a large part of student expenses, especially for those students who live off campus, is not captured in University spending.
These student and family expenses include off-campus meals and entertainment, clothing and other retail purchases, and family visitation expenses. Table 9 estimates these additional annual costs for the average student. The analysis assumes that the average full-time student will receive overnight visitors once per year and that the average student will spend approximately $1,500 during that time period on outside meals, retail expenditures, entertainment and services.
As the table indicates, off-budget family expenses totaled more than $238 million and led to indirect effects on output of approximately an additional $178.5 million, for a total economic impact of more than $416 million.
Category | Direct Effect | Indirect Effect | Total Effect |
---|---|---|---|
Family Expenses | $238,097,420 | $178,573,065 | $416,670,485 |
State colleges and universities offer substantially lower in-state tuition than private universities. But an additional attraction is that these schools appeal to commuters, who can enjoy further savings by avoiding on-campus housing and related costs. So, geographic proximity is an important consideration. Indeed, well-established literature finds that travel distance to public colleges and universities substantially affects student enrollments and graduations. Specifically, greater distance has been found to significantly reduce enrollment.
By virtue of its location, Stony Brook University provides educational opportunity to residents of Long Island and downstate New York. If Stony Brook University were unavailable, many students would have to travel significantly farther to attend a public university. For example, Stony Brook is about 45 miles from SUNY Old Westbury, 25 miles from Farmingdale State College and more than 50 miles from The City University of New York schools. Private universities are generally much more expensive and would not be an option for many students.
Based upon a review of the available literature on students’ distance from college and the effects of distance on enrollment, it is conservatively estimated that but for the availability of Stony Brook University, 5 percent of its students each year would not have graduated from college. This is a very conservative assumption, given estimates from the literature (references below). These college graduates will enjoy a significantly higher wage than high school graduates. Available evidence from the Bureau of Labor Statistics indicates that four-year college graduates earn on average about $25,000 more per year than high school graduates. And this will be true for such students in each of Stony Brook’s graduating classes. Assuming that individuals work on average for 40 years, this increased earnings productivity will accrue for 5 percent of students in each of Stony Brook’s prior 40 years of graduating classes.
Similar calculations were made to estimate the additional benefits from education beyond college degrees, again assuming that but for the availability of Stony Brook University, 5 percent of these students with advanced degrees (master’s, doctorates and professional degrees) would not have received these degrees and the resulting higher incomes, but would have stopped after having obtained their college degrees.
The effects of enhanced human capital and worker productivity are substantial. As Table 10 demonstrates, enhanced worker productivity increased output by nearly $767 million in 2016.
Category | Direct Effect | Indirect Effect | Total Effect |
---|---|---|---|
Worker Productivity | $438,274,250 | $328,705,688 | $766,979,938 |
In addition to increasing economic output, Stony Brook University adds substantially to earnings of workers in the region. Tables 11–15 show the effects of economic development, operating expenditures, capital expenditures, off-budget family expenditures and enhanced worker productivity on earnings.
The tables reveal that each category leads to substantially higher earnings:
Category | Direct Effect | Indirect Effect | Total Effect |
---|---|---|---|
Economic Development | $230,643* | $158,724,190 | $158,954,833 |
*This figure refers only to earnings related to the design expenditures reported in Table 6, and not to the earnings supported by external awards to the Office of Economic Development.
Category | Direct Effect | Indirect Effect | Total Effect |
---|---|---|---|
Instruction | $144,924,274 | $134,649,143 | $279,573,417 |
Research | $39,857,082 | $37,031,215 | $76,888,297 |
Public Service | $9,592,668 | $8,912,548 | $18,505,216 |
Academic Support | $30,045,475 | $24,826,561 | $54,872,036 |
Student Services | $17,974,271 | $16,699,895 | $34,674,166 |
Institutional Support | $43,128,067 | $35,636,722 | $78,764,789 |
Operation & Maintenance | $22,624,338 | $18,065,534 | $40,689,872 |
Scholarships & Fellowships | $9,072,815 | $8,429,553 | $17,502,368 |
Auxiliary Enterprises | $24,579,825 | $19,238,629 | $43,818,454 |
Hospital Services | $410,601,336 | $399,597,220 | $810,198,556 |
Dental Services | $488,975 | $459,153 | $948,128 |
Clinical Services | $126,860,042 | $119,123,058 | $245,983,100 |
Other Expenses & Deductions | $2,988,282 | $2,776,413 | $5,764,695 |
Interest Expenses | $16,347,499 | $19,831,151 | $36,178,650 |
Total | $899,084,949 | $845,276,795 | $1,744,361,744 |
Category | Direct Efect | Indirect Effect | Total Effect |
---|---|---|---|
Construction | $84,553,433 | $69,815,770 | $154,369,203 |
Equipment | $6,894,922 | $5,468,363 | $12,363,285 |
Land | $1,605,571 | $892,216 | $2,497,787 |
Interest Expenses | $3,433,377 | $4,165,030 | $7,598,407 |
Total | $96,487,303 | $80,341,379 | $176,828,682 |
Category | Direct Effect | Indirect Effect | Total Effect |
---|---|---|---|
Family Expenses | $63,946,164 | $47,959,623 | $111,905,787 |
Category | Direct Effect | Indirect Effect | Total Effect |
---|---|---|---|
Worker Productivity | $112,636,054 | $84,477,040 | $197,113,094 |
Stony Brook University supports many jobs. Tables 16–20 show the effects of economic development, operating expenditures, capital expenditures, off-budget family expenditures and enhanced worker productivity on jobs.
The tables reveal that each category creates large numbers of jobs:
Category | Direct Effect | Indirect Effect | Total Effect |
---|---|---|---|
Economic Development | 6* | 4,308 | 4,314 |
*This jobs number is derived from Table 11, Earnings, and Table 6, Output, and does not reflect the 892.5 private-sector jobs created/retained by VPED industry partners, making a grand total of 5,206.5 regional jobs from Economic Developement activities.
Category | Direct Effect | Indirect Effect | Total Effect |
---|---|---|---|
Instruction | 3,934 | 3,655 | 7,589 |
Research | 1,082 | 1,055 | 2,087 |
Public Service | 260 | 242 | 502 |
Academic Support | 844 | 698 | 1,542 |
Student Services | 488 | 453 | 941 |
Institutional Support | 1,212 | 1,002 | 2,214 |
Operation & Maintenance | 545 | 435 | 980 |
Scholarships & Fellowships | 246 | 229 | 475 |
Auxiliary Enterprises | 942 | 737 | 1,679 |
Hospital Services | 7,827 | 7,616 | 15,443 |
Dental Services | 9 | 9 | 18 |
Clinical Services | 2,398 | 2,251 | 4,649 |
Other Expenses & Deductions | 81 | 75 | 156 |
Interest Expenses | 313 | 380 | 693 |
Total | 20,181 | 18,787 | 38,968 |
Category | Direct Efect | Indirect Effect | Total Effect |
---|---|---|---|
Construction | 1,692 | 1,397 | 3,089 |
Equipment | 126 | 100 | 226 |
Land | 50 | 28 | 78 |
Interest Expenses | 66 | 80 | 146 |
Total | 1,934 | 1,605 | 3,539 |
Category | Direct Effect | Indirect Effect | Total Effect |
---|---|---|---|
Off-Budget Family Expenses | 1,619 | 1,214 | 2,833 |
Category | Direct Effect | Indirect Effect | Total Effect |
---|---|---|---|
Worker Productivity | 2,852 | 2,139 | 4,991 |
Table 21 combines the results reported earlier to show aggregate effects on output, earnings and jobs. The numbers are very large. In 2016, Stony Brook University:
These numbers are all the more impressive considering that $7.23 billion represents about 3 percent of Long Island’s annual GDP.
Direct Effect | Indirect Effect | Total Effect | |
---|---|---|---|
Economic Impact on Output | |||
Economic Development (Table 6) | $654,024 | $233,607,654 | $234,261,678 |
Operating Expenditures (Table 7) | $2,690,841,643 | $2,529,723,107 | $5,220,564,750 |
Capital Expenditures (Table 8) | $322,673,451 | $267,988,250 | $590,661,701 |
Off-Budget Family Expenses (Table 9) | $238,097,420 | $178,573,065 | $416,670,485 |
Enhanced Worker Productivity (Table 10) | $438,274,250 | $328,705,688 | $766,979,938 |
Grand Total Impact on Output | $3,690,540,788 | $3,538,597,764 | $7,229,138,552 |
Economic Impact on Earnings | |||
Economic Development (Table 11) | $230,643 | $158,724,190 | $158,954,833 |
Operating Expenditures (Table 12) | $899,084,949 | $845,276,795 | $1,744,361,744 |
Capital Expenditures (Table 13) | $96,487,303 | $80,341,379 | $176,828,682 |
Off-Budget Family Expenses (Table 14) | $63,946,164 | $47,959,623 | $111,905,787 |
Enhanced Worker Productivity (Table 15) | $112,636,054 | $84,477,040 | $197,113,094 |
Grand Total Impact on Earnings | $1,172,385,113 | $1,216,779,027 | $2,389,164,140 |
Economic Impact on Jobs | |||
Economic Development (Table 16) | 6 | 4,308 | 4,314 |
Operating Expenditures (Table 17) | 20,181 | 18,787 | 38,968 |
Capital Expenditures (Table 18) | 1,934 | 1,605 | 3,539 |
Off-Budget Family Expenses (Table 19) | 1,619 | 1,214 | 2,833 |
Enhanced Worker Productivity (Table 20) | 2,852 | 2,139 | 4,991 |
Grand Total Impact on Jobs | 26,592 | 28,053 | 54,645 |
Of course, the main mission of any institution of higher learning is to enhance human capital. And Stony Brook has done more than its share of that. Table 22 estimates the aggregate annual effect of all Stony Brook graduates on output, earnings and jobs supported. In 2016, Stony Brook graduates:
Category | Direct Effect | Indirect Effect | Total Effect |
---|---|---|---|
Output | $8,765,485,000 | $6,574,113,750 | $15,339,598,750 |
Earnings | $2,252,721,079 | $1,689,540,809 | $3,942,261,888 |
Jobs | 57,037 | 42,778 | 99,815 |
Note: Table 22 shows the economic impacts of increased earnings of all SBU graduates in a single year. It assumes individuals work for 40 years, so that these effects include graduates from the past 40 years.
The economic impact of Stony Brook University is assessed using input-output (I-O) models. An input-output model quantifies the flows of economic activity within a region. The model captures what each business or sector must purchase from every other sector to produce a dollar's worth of goods or services. The economic impact of spending on a project consists of three components: direct, indirect and induced effects. Direct effects are quantified as the spending for the project itself; for example, the successful bid by a defense contractor to manufacture aircraft. In this example, indirect effects are the changes in sales, income or jobs in sectors within the region that supply goods and services to the aerospace sector. The increased need for drafting firms, tools, equipment and sheet metal resulting from the awarding of the contract is an indirect effect of project spending. Induced effects are the increased sales within the region from household spending of the income earned in the aerospace and other sectors that support the manufacturing of the aircraft. Contractor employees and workers on the project spend the income they earn on housing, utilities, groceries, etc. These represent induced effects. Because the project may require the hiring of additional employees, and the region will be adding residents who will also spend, their effects on economic activity are quantified as well.
Multipliers are used to quantify all three effects — direct, indirect and induced. These multipliers are developed from input-output tables produced by the Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA). Since the 1970s, the BEA has produced regional I-O multipliers that quantify inter-industry purchases resulting from changes in final demand. The multipliers produced by the model are customized to account for the economic activity in any set of contiguous U.S. counties. Multipliers show the total effect on economic activity resulting from a project. For example, a project costing $1 million might generate economic output of $1.8 million once direct and induced effects are added to the cost of the project itself. There are several measures of changes in total economic activity that one may estimate — gross output, earnings and employment.
Gross output is equal to the sum of the intermediate inputs and value added. It can also be measured as the sum of the intermediate inputs and final use. Gross output is a duplicative total in that goods and services will be counted multiple times if they are used in the production of other goods and services.
Earnings consist of wages and salaries and proprietors’ income. Employer contributions for health insurance are also included. Personal contributions to social insurance and employee pension plans are excluded because the model must account for only the portion of personal income that is currently available for households to spend.
Employment consists of a count of jobs that include both full-time and part-time workers.
State colleges and universities offer substantially lower in-state tuition than private universities. But an additional attraction is that these schools appeal to commuters, who can enjoy further savings by avoiding on-campus housing and related costs. So, geographic proximity is an important consideration as well. Indeed, well-established literature finds that travel distance to public colleges and universities substantially affects student enrollments and graduations. Specifically, greater distance has been found to reduce enrollment significantly (Alm and Winters, 2009; McConnell, 1965; Kariel, 1968; Ullis and Knowles, 1975; Leppel, 1993; Ordovensky, 1995; Desjardins, Dundar and Hendel, 1999; and Ali, 2003).
Stony Brook has many commuter students. If Stony Brook University were unavailable, many students would have to travel significantly farther to attend a public university. For example, Stony Brook is about 45 miles from SUNY Old Westbury, 25 miles from Farmingdale State College and more than 50 miles from The City University of New York schools. Private universities are generally much more expensive and would not be an option for many students.
Based upon a review of the available literature on students’ distance from college and the effects of distance on enrollment, it is conservatively estimated that but for the availability of Stony Brook University, 5 percent of its students each year would not have graduated from college. This is a very conservative assumption, given estimates from the literature (references below). These college graduates will enjoy a significantly higher wage than high school graduates. Available evidence from the Bureau of Labor Statistics indicates that four-year college graduates earn on average about $25,000 more per year than high school graduates. And this will be true for such students in each of Stony Brook’s graduating classes. Assuming that individuals work on average for 40 years, this increased earnings productivity will accrue for 5 percent of students in each of Stony Brook’s prior 40 years of graduating classes.
Thus, total increased earnings for each year (EARNSTOT) may be estimated in the following equation as:
EARNSTOT = PCTSTUDENTS*WAGEPREMIUM*∑STUDENTSi, i = 1… 40
Where:
PCTSTUDENTS = percent of students who would not have graduated college but for the availability of Stony Brook
WAGEPREMIUM = increased average annual earnings of college graduates vs. high school graduates
∑STUDENTSi = number of students graduating from Stony Brook over a 40-year time period
To calculate total economic impacts for output, earnings and jobs, the equation must be multiplied by the appropriate multipliers for each of these categories. We used the average values of RIMS multipliers across all industries for output, earnings and employment to obtain these values.
Similar calculations were made to estimate the additional benefits from education beyond college degrees, again assuming that but for the availability of Stony Brook University, 5 percent of these students with advanced degrees (master’s, doctorates and professional degrees) would not have obtained these degrees and the resulting higher incomes, but would have stopped after having obtained their college degrees.
Ali, M.K. (2003). Analysis of enrollment: A spatial-interaction model. The Journal of Economics, 29(2), 67–86.
Alm, J. and Winters, J. (2009). Distance and intrastate college student migration. Economics of Education Review, 28, 728–738.
Desjardins, S.L., Dundar, H. and Hendel, D.D. (1999). Modeling the college application process in a land-grant university. Economics of Education Review, 18(1), 117–132.
Kariel, H.G. (1968). Student enrollment and spatial interaction. Annals of Regional Science, 2(1), 114–127.
Leppel, K. (1993). Logit estimation of a gravity model of the college enrollment decision. Research in Higher Education, 34(3), 387–398.
McConnell, H. (1965). Spatial variability of college enrollment as a function of migration potential. The Professional Geographer, 17(6), 29–37.
Ordovensky, J.F. (1995). Effects of institutional attributes on enrollment choice: Implications for postsecondary vocational education. Economics of Education Review, 14(4), 335–350.
Ullis, J.J. and Knowles, P.L. (1975). A study of the intrastate migration of Washington college freshmen: A further test of the gravity model. Annals of Regional Science, 9(1), 112–121.
Stony Brook University/SUNY is an affirmative action, equal opportunity educator and employer. 18120764